Skip to content

Reloader Special 5 vs Rock Chucker Supreme: Pick the Right Press

By Updated 6 min read

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no cost to you.

On this page (8 sections)
  1. The differences at a glance
  2. O-frame vs C-frame: how much rigidity you actually need
  3. Priming: clean chute vs classic arm
  4. Linkage feel: smoothness versus power
  5. Value: what you get per dollar
  6. Which should you buy?
  7. The bottom line
  8. Frequently asked questions

You are choosing between two single-stage presses that will live on your bench for years. One is the budget-friendly option with smart features, and the other is the long-standing benchmark for rigidity. This page breaks down exactly where each one wins so you can match the tool to how you actually reload.

In short: For most readers, the Hornady Reloader Special 5 wins on value and ease of use, with its C-frame accessibility and automatic primer chute making daily reloading less fussy.

The RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme wins on pure frame rigidity and mechanical smoothness, which matters if you plan to run long-range rifle or large magnum calibers and want a press that is effectively indestructible. Your call depends on which of those two priorities comes first.

Quick picks

Our shortlist for this job · tap one to see today's price
Best for value-focused and beginnerHornady 085001 Lock-N-Load Classic Ammo Reloading Press

The C-frame and automatic primer chute reduce bench mess and case handling friction for everyday use.

Check price on Amazon
Best for precision and lifetime-pressInline Fabrication Ergonomic Roller Lever

The O-frame and ultra-smooth linkage give you a consistent stroke for precision rifle work.

Check price on Amazon

The differences at a glance

Reloader Special 5 vs Rock Chucker Supreme: Pick the Right Press

The two presses share the same job: resize, prime, seat, and crimp. But the way they get there is different. The table below isolates the specs that actually change how you sit at the bench. For the detail, see our notes on assessing special 5 value.

Feature RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme Hornady Reloader Special 5
Frame design Enclosed O-frame, cast iron Open C-frame, cast iron
Primer handling Removable primer arm, drop-through ram Automatic primer catcher with chute
Linkage feel Very smooth, consistent stroke Powerful, slight cam-over at end of stroke
Typical price point Premium Budget-friendly / value
Best fit Precision rifle, high-volume, “buy once” reloaders Beginners, value-driven buyers, smaller hands may prefer C-frame access

O-frame vs C-frame: how much rigidity you actually need

The Rock Chucker Supreme’s O-frame wraps a full ring of cast iron around the ram, which minimizes flex under load. The Reloader Special 5’s C-frame is open on one side, giving you clear access to the case and die stack.

For most everyday calibers like .308 Winchester or 9mm, both frames are more than rigid enough. The O-frame advantage shows up when you start cranking out large magnum rifle cases or when you are chasing match-level consistency over tens of thousands of rounds.

If rigidity is the top line in your buying criteria, the Rock Chucker Supreme wins this factor. If bench access and easy case placement are your priority, the Reloader Special 5’s C-frame is the better fit.

Pro tip: Both frames are cast iron and will last decades. Check the maker’s current spec sheet for the exact frame material and weight if you need a number for your bench load.

Recommended for this stepInline Fabrication Ergonomic Roller Lever

Its O-frame gives you the unyielding base for large rifle cases and long-term heavy use.

  • Each lever is designed for maximum ergonomic benefit with a specific press, please
  • The bends of the Ergonomic Lever series keeps the lever travel distance the same, but
Check price on Amazon

Priming: clean chute vs classic arm

The Reloader Special 5 routes every spent primer through a built-in chute into a sealed container. You never have a pile of primers on the bench, and you do not need to stop mid-session to clear the ram.

The Rock Chucker Supreme uses a traditional removable primer arm that drops spent primers through the ram into a tube or bottle you attach. It is simple, well-proven, and easy to clean. Some reloaders prefer it because there is less moving machinery to jam. It helps to understand measuring press footprint before going further.

The automatic chute is a genuine convenience win for the Reloader Special 5, especially if you are a beginner who wants the least possible cleanup. The Rock Chucker’s priming arm is not worse, just older in approach.

Recommended for this stepHornady 085001 Lock-N-Load Classic Ammo Reloading Press

The integrated primer chute keeps your workbench clear and saves you a stop between every dozen rounds.

  • Lnl classic loader
  • Each lock-n-load classic press Comes with primer catcher and three lock-n-load DIE
Check price on Amazon

Linkage feel: smoothness versus power

Both presses use a compound linkage that gives you mechanical advantage. The Rock Chucker Supreme’s linkage is consistently described as buttery smooth across the whole stroke, with no sudden break or cam-over at the top.

The Reloader Special 5 linkage is powerful and easy to pull, but many owners note a slight cam-over just before the stroke completes. It is not a defect; it is a tactile difference you will feel after using the Rock Chucker side-by-side.

If you are sensitive to how a press feels in your hand and you value a perfectly even stroke, the Rock Chucker Supreme wins this factor. If you just need a strong, easy pull, the Reloader Special 5 does the job without issue.

Pro tip: A difference in cam-over does not change case quality. It changes the feel under your hand, which matters if you load high volume and do not want to fatigue.

Value: what you get per dollar

The Reloader Special 5 sits in the budget-friendly price range and includes the automatic primer chute as standard. You are paying less for a press that covers 95% of what most hand-loaders do, every day.

The Rock Chucker Supreme commands a premium. That price buys the O-frame, the smoother linkage, the long track record, and the reputation for outlasting everything else on the bench. Reloaders who call it “buy once, cry once” are in that camp.

If you are starting out or running a mix of pistol and rifle calibers on a tight budget, the Reloader Special 5 is the stronger value. The money you save can go toward a good scale, dies, or a starter set of primers.

Which should you buy?

  • You are a beginner or budget-focused reloader and want a clean, easy-to-use press: get the Hornady Reloader Special 5. The C-frame and primer chute make the first sessions less intimidating.
  • You reload primarily rifle calibers for precision or long range and want the most rigid base: get the RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme. The O-frame and smooth linkage are built for that workload.
  • You plan to load large magnum cases in high volume and view the press as a decades-long tool: the Rock Chucker Supreme’s rigidity and finish justify the premium.
  • You value bench access and easy case placement over raw frame stiffness: the Reloader Special 5’s open C-frame is the better ergonomic fit.

The bottom line

Most readers will get the best match with the Hornady Reloader Special 5: it is cheaper, easier to clean, and the open C-frame makes case handling quicker for everyday pistol and rifle work.

If you load long-range rifle calibers at volume or want the absolute most rigid, smooth-acting press for the next twenty years, the RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme is the one to buy.

Start by listing your top three calibers and your monthly round goal; if large magnum rifle is on that list, the O-frame pays for itself.

Our top pickHornady 085001 Lock-N-Load Classic Ammo Reloading Press
  • Lnl classic loader
  • Each lock-n-load classic press Comes with primer catcher and three lock-n-load DIE
Check price on Amazon

Frequently asked questions

Is the Hornady Reloader Special 5 good for beginners?

Yes. The C-frame makes it easy to see and grip the case at every step, and the automatic primer chute means you are not cleaning primers off the bench after every handful of rounds. The lower price point also lets a new reloader invest in dies and a good scale without the press eating the entire budget.

Can the Rock Chucker Supreme handle .338 Lapua Magnum without frame flex?

The O-frame is designed to resist flex under heavy loads, and .338 Lapua Magnum is within the class of cases the Rock Chucker is built for. Many long-range reloaders run it at that caliber without issue. Check RCBS’s current spec sheet for the maximum cartridge case length they list for the 9356 to confirm it covers your specific round.

Which press is easier to clean and maintain?

The Reloader Special 5 is easier for most users. The primer chute keeps spent primers off the bench, and the open C-frame gives you more access to wipe down the die stack and the shell holder. The other half of this decision is rcbs 6.5 crm.

The Rock Chucker’s enclosed O-frame requires a bit more reaching to get around the ram area, though both presses have few external parts to maintain.

Do I need a separate primer dispenser with either press?

No. Both presses have built-in primers that you load into the ram. The Rock Chucker uses a removable primer arm; the Reloader Special 5 uses a fixed primer station. Either way, you can use a hand primer or the press’s built-in option without buying an extra tool.

What is the weight difference between the two, and does it matter?

The Rock Chucker Supreme is generally the heavier of the two because of the full O-frame. The extra mass adds stability and can reduce vibration during high-volume sessions. The Reloader Special 5 is lighter, which makes it easier to move or mount on a benchtop.

Check the maker’s current spec sheet for the exact weight if bench load is a concern.