Lyman All-American 8 vs RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme
By Amis Thains Updated 5 min read
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no cost to you.
On this page (8 sections)
You are trying to decide between a fast turret system and a rugged single-stage classic, but the difference in workflow and included gear is hard to quantify. This comparison breaks down exactly how the Lyman All-American 8 and RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme differ in build, speed, and value so you can pick the right press without guesswork.
In short: The RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme wins for most readers who want a complete, beginner-friendly kit that includes a scale, powder measure, and priming tools. The Lyman All-American 8 is the better choice if you prioritize speed on multiple calibers and do not mind sourcing separate accessories. For most people starting out, the RCBS kit is the practical path; for high-volume turret shooters, the Lyman is the faster workflow.
Quick picks
Our shortlist for this job · tap one to see today's priceReplaces the hand tool with an auto pricer to cut batch time on the Rock Chucker.
Attaches to the Lyman press to catch spent primers and keep your bench clean.
The differences at a glance
The core split is simple: one is a turret, the other is a single-stage. The RCBS kit is a bundle; the Lyman is a standalone press. Here is how the two stack up on the bench. If that sounds like your bench, read up on comparing rc models next.
| Feature | RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme | Lyman All-American 8 |
|---|---|---|
| Press Type | Single-Stage (O-Frame) | Turret (8-Station) |
| Kit Contents | Press, Scale, Powder Measure, Priming Tool, Manual | Press Only |
| Workflow Style | Batch processing (one operation at a time) | Sequential processing (one case at a time) |
| Best For | Beginners, Precision Rifle Loads | High-Volume Pistol, Multiple Calibers |
Build quality and structural rigidity
Both presses use cast iron, but the frame design changes how they feel. The Rock Chucker uses a massive O-frame that is widely regarded as the industry standard for strength. The Lyman All-American 8 features a turret head mounted on a similar heavy body.
The RCBS O-frame is a monolithic block. When you resize full-length rifle brass, the press does not move. This rigidity is why many precision shooters prefer it. The Lyman turret has more moving parts in the indexing mechanism, which some users feel adds a slight variable compared to a fixed single-stage block.
Winner: RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme. The O-frame offers the most solid feel for heavy resizing operations.
- A solid press built for sizing, seating, and full‑length work.
- UNIQUE UP‑STROKE DESIGN: The case stays put while the die moves down, giving you a
Accuracy and precision for consistent loads
For benchrest or long-range targets, the single-stage process offers a tighter control loop. You handle each case individually for every step, which reduces the chance of a loaded round moving between stages.
The Lyman turret is perfectly capable of high precision for most sport and tactical loads. However, if you are chasing grouping at 1000 yards, the fixed die setup of the Rock Chucker is the safer bet. The turret mechanism, while excellent, introduces a rotating element that some elite loaders prefer to avoid.
Winner: RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme. It is the preferred tool for the most demanding precision shooting. It helps to understand rcbs supreme master review before going further.
Pro tip: Check the bore alignment of any turret press you buy. A misaligned turret can cause bullet seating issues that do not show up on a single-stage.
Speed and workflow efficiency
The Lyman All-American 8 is faster for most tasks. You drop a case into the holder, rotate the turret to size, rotate to prime, rotate to charge, rotate to seat, and pull the case. It is done.
On the Rock Chucker, you process all cases through one die, then all through the next. This is slower but creates a natural check for errors. If you are loading 500 rounds of 9mm, the Lyman turret will finish the job in half the time. The speed advantage is real and significant for high-volume work.
Winner: Lyman All-American 8. It cuts down the total bench time for large batches of a single caliber.
Ease of use for beginners
The RCBS kit is designed to hold your hand. You get a scale, a powder measure, and a priming tool in the box. The manual walks you through the process using the specific tools included. There is no hunting for compatible parts.
The Lyman press requires you to buy a scale, powder measure, and caseprep tools separately. This offers customization but adds friction. You must ensure your powder measure matches your turret’s magazine or use a separate pour. For a first-time loader, the RCBS kit removes the research burden. For the detail, see our notes on lyman all-american press.
Winner: RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme. The all-in-one approach makes the first day on the bench much less stressful.
The auto priming tool included in the RCBS kit can be swapped for this upgrade later to speed up the most repetitive step.
- RCBS RC Supreme Auto Prime: Automatic priming tool for faster reloading; provides
- Reliable Reloading: Provides precise resizing and bullet seating for .22 Hornet
Value and what is included in the box
The RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme is sold as a “Master Kit” that includes the press, M500 scale, Uniflow-III powder measure, and priming tools. The Lyman All-American 8 is sold as a press only.
When you add the cost of a digital scale, powder measure, and case lube to match the Lyman, the total entry price rises. The RCBS kit provides the complete starting system for a lower total outlay. The Lyman is a better value only if you already own a scale and powder measure.
Winner: RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme. It delivers the most reloading capability per dollar spent.
If you buy the Lyman, add this primer catcher to keep your bench clean and recover spent heads.
- Catch spent primers
- No primers on the floor
The bottom line
Buy the RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme if you want a complete, beginner-friendly kit that covers every step of reloading without extra shopping. Buy the Lyman All-American 8 if you want the fastest workflow for high-volume pistol loads and already have a scale and powder measure. Most readers should start with the RCBS kit to learn the fundamentals properly.
- RCBS RC Supreme Auto Prime: Automatic priming tool for faster reloading; provides
- Reliable Reloading: Provides precise resizing and bullet seating for .22 Hornet
Frequently asked questions
Can I use RCBS dies in a Lyman turret press?
Yes. Standard 7/8-14 threaded dies are universal. You can run RCBS, Hornady, or Lee dies on the Lyman All-American 8 turret without issue.
Which press is better for loading .223 rifle?
The RCBS Rock Chucker is generally preferred for .223 due to its rigid O-frame. The Lyman turret works fine, but the single-stage allows for more meticulous case preparation which helps with precision.
Does the Lyman All-American 8 come with a powder measure?
No. The Lyman All-American 8 is sold as a standalone press. You must purchase a powder measure, scale, and case prep tools separately to complete the reloading setup.
Is the turret mechanism on the Lyman prone to wear?
It is a mechanical part, so it will wear over decades of use. However, many owners report that Lyman turrets are robust. Regular cleaning and lubrication of the turret axis prevents stiffness or skipping.


