Two names dominate the conversation when shooters decide to step up their reloading game: Hornady and Dillon Precision. Each represents a distinct philosophy in the world of progressive reloading presses, and choosing between them often feels like picking a side. The Hornady 085001 Lock-N-Load Classic and the Dillon Precision RL550C are both formidable machines, but they cater to different priorities and workflows. My honest assessment is that this isn’t just a comparison of features, but of fundamental approaches to making ammunition.
Honest OpinionThis head-to-head will break down their actual capabilities, stripping away the marketing to focus on what each press truly offers. We’ll examine the core differences in operation, the tangible value each brings to your bench, and who will benefit most from each design. Speaking honestly, the right choice depends entirely on your specific reloading goals, volume needs, and personal preferences.
Head-to-Head Overview: Hornady Lock-N-Load vs Dillon RL550C
At first glance, both are progressive presses designed to produce finished rounds with each pull of the handle. The divergence is immediate and significant. The Hornady Lock-N-Load Classic is built around its namesake bushing system, promising swift die changes. It arrives with a primer catcher and three of these bushings right in the box. Dillon’s RL550C, on the other hand, champions manual indexing and a removable toolhead system. Its value proposition leans heavily on durability, user control, and the company’s legendary support.
The RL550C emphasizes “precision reloading with progressive efficiency,” aiming to bridge the gap between single-stage consistency and progressive speed. Its case-activated powder measure and greaseable pivot pin speak to a design built for the long haul. The Hornady press focuses on simplifying the process for the reloader who values adaptability and a streamlined setup. Honestly speaking, one isn’t universally better; they are tools optimized for different tasks.
Detailed Feature-by-Feature Comparison
Let’s get into the specifics. This side-by-side look is based solely on the features and descriptions provided for each product.
| Feature | Hornady 085001 Lock-N-Load Classic | Dillon Precision RL550C |
|---|---|---|
| Core Operation | Auto-indexing progressive press | Manual indexing progressive press |
| Die Changing System | Lock-N-Load bushing system (3 included) | Removable toolhead system |
| Included Accessories | Primer catcher, three Lock-N-Load die bushings | Case-activated powder measure |
| Key Design Focus | Quick die changes, streamlined operation | User control, durability, precision |
| Powder Dispensing | Not specified in provided features | Case-activated (dispenses only when case is present) |
| Construction & Service | Made by Hornady | Greaseable lower pivot pin, made in the USA, backed by “unbeatable customer service” |
| Check current price on Amazon | Check current price on Amazon |
Indexing: Automation vs. Control
The auto-indexing of the Hornady press advances the shell plate automatically with each stroke. This is fantastic for developing a rhythmic, high-volume reloading pace. The Dillon RL550C requires you to manually rotate the shell plate between stations. From my honest perspective, this manual step is not a drawback but a feature. It allows you to visually inspect and feel each case at every stage, which is a massive benefit for reloading for beginners or when working on precision rifle loads. You have complete oversight, reducing the chance of a double-charge or other error going unnoticed.
Die & Caliber Change Systems
This is where the philosophies clash most visibly. Hornady’s Lock-N-Load bushings let you pre-set your dies and snap them in or out of the press head without adjusting the die itself. It’s incredibly fast. Dillon’s system uses a removable toolheadthe entire cluster of dies and the powder measure comes out as one unit. Your settings are preserved perfectly. For someone who reloads multiple calibers frequently, the speed of the Hornady is appealing. For the reloader who wants absolute, repeatable precision and doesn’t mind storing complete toolheads, the Dillon system is superb. You can read more about press precision in our other comparisons.
The Primer System and Other Considerations
The Hornady includes a primer catcher, a thoughtful addition for keeping your bench clean. The RL550C’s primer system is part of its robust, case-activated design. Dillon’s emphasis on a greaseable pivot pin for “long-lasting performance” directly addresses long-term maintenancea missing entity in many reloading press reviews. Thinking about noise and vibration, the solid, cast construction of both presses dampens sound well, though the manual indexing of the 550C creates a different, perhaps more deliberate, operational rhythm. Bench space is similar, but the Dillon’s toolhead storage might require a bit more planning.
Price, Value, and Cost of Ownership Analysis
A strict Dillon RL550C vs Hornady Lock-N-Load price comparison only tells part of the story. The initial purchase price is one thing; the long-term value proposition is another. The Hornady press comes with those three bushings, which is a direct value add if you plan to use that system. The Dillon includes its well-regarded case-activated powder measure, a significant component you’d otherwise purchase separately.
Dillon’s famous “no-BS warranty” and customer service are part of the product’s cost equation. Knowing you have legendary support behind your press can justify a higher initial investment. Hornady also provides solid support. From my honest perspective, you must factor in the cost of additional accessories. For the Hornady, you’ll likely want more Lock-N-Load bushings. For the Dillon, you’ll want additional toolheads for each caliber. These ongoing costs balance out over time.
Ideal User Profile: Who Should Buy Which Press?
The Hornady Lock-N-Load AP Buyer
This press is an excellent candidate for the best progressive press for beginner reloader who wants automation without overwhelming complexity. It’s also ideal for:
- Reloaders who frequently switch between multiple calibers in a single session.
- Those who prioritize a streamlined, automated process for high volume reloading of pistol or standard rifle ammunition.
- Shooters who appreciate a system that gets them running quickly with minimal fuss.
The Dillon RL550C Buyer
This machine shines for the detail-oriented reloader. It’s the press to choose for Hornady Lock-N-Load vs Dillon RL550C for precision rifle work. Its ideal user includes:
- Reloaders who value absolute control and inspection at each stage.
- Precision rifle shooters who need to feel confident in every round.
- Anyone who prioritizes monumental durability and top-tier customer service.
- Those comfortable with a slightly more involved reloading press setup for greater long-term payoff.
If you’re curious about other presses that emphasize control, our look at a precision turret option might interest you.
Final Verdict and Recommendations
So, which is easier to set up, Hornady or Dillon press? Honestly speaking, the Hornady’s auto-indexing and simple bushing system make initial setup and operation very straightforward. The Dillon requires understanding its manual process, but its toolhead system makes subsequent caliber changes just as fast, if not faster, once you’re organized.
My honest take is this: if your goal is efficient, automated production of quality ammunition for high-volume shooting, the Hornady Lock-N-Load Classic is a fantastic and logical choice. It simplifies the progressive process effectively.
If your reloading ethos leans toward meticulous control, unparalleled durability, and building a system for a lifetime of precision, the Dillon RL550C is worth every penny. Its manual indexing is a teacher of good habits and a guardian against errors.
Both are outstanding pieces of reloading equipment. Your decision hinges on whether you want the press to manage the process for you or you want to manage every detail of the process yourself. For more foundational information, always consult an authority guide on safe reloading practices. And remember, this Honest Opinion comes from years of seeing what works on the bench. Your perfect press is the one that aligns with how you actually shoot and reload.