Choosing your first, or next, single stage press is a big deal. It’s the cornerstone of your reloading bench, a tool you’ll use for years. Two names consistently rise to the top: the RCBS Rebel and the Reloader Special 5. Both are workhorses from a legendary brand, but they cater to slightly different sensibilities.
This isn’t just about specs on paper. It’s about feel, workflow, and long-term satisfaction. We’re going to break down every nut and bolt. For those seeking a benchmark of proven performance, many experienced reloaders point to the RCBS 9356 Rock Chucker Supreme as the gold standard in its class. It’s a great reference point as we explore these two contenders.
The Contenders: RCBS Rebel & Reloader Special 5
RCBS has built its reputation on durability. The Reloader Special 5 is a modern evolution of a classic design, a direct descendant of presses that have loaded millions of rounds. The Rebel is the newer kid on the block, engineered with some thoughtful updates aimed at the contemporary reloader. Both are single stage press champions, but their approaches differ.
Think of it as choosing between a refined classic car and a modern truck. Both will get you there reliably, but the experience behind the wheel varies. Your choice hinges on what you value most: timeless simplicity or integrated modern convenience.
Head-to-Head Feature Comparison
Let’s get into the tangible differences. This is where you’ll see the divergence in philosophy between these two presses.
Frame & Construction: The Foundation
This is the most critical difference. The Reloader Special 5 uses a traditional C-frame construction. It’s open on the front, which offers fantastic access for handling cases and bullets. The Rebel, however, employs a full O-frame construction. This closed-loop design is renowned for superior rigidity and alignment, which can translate to more consistent sizing and seating operations.
In the debate of O-frame vs C-frame, the O-frame generally wins on sheer stiffness. The Rebel’s design minimizes flex, a key factor for precision reloading. The Reloader Special 5’s C-frame is no slouch, but it’s a different kind of robust.
Leverage & Linkage: The Muscle
Both presses provide ample reloading press leverage. The Reloader Special 5 uses a straightforward linkage system that has proven itself over decades. The Rebel introduces a compound linkage system. This design provides exceptional mechanical advantage, making the final portion of the ram strokelike swaging primer pockets or sizing tough brassnoticeably smoother.
You’ll appreciate that compound action on stubborn .308 or .30-06 cases. It reduces operator fatigue, which matters during long reloading sessions.
Primer Handling: A Key Workflow Divider
Here’s a major practical differentiator. The Reloader Special 5 features a classic, swing-out primer arm. It works perfectly well but leaves spent primers to drop freely, which you then have to manage with a tube or cup.
The Rebel tackles spent primer management head-on. It includes a built-in, positive primer catcher system that channels spent primers directly into a removable tube. This is a huge upgrade for bench cleanliness and is one of the Rebel’s most praised features. A good reloading press primer catcher keeps your workspace tidy and safe.
Performance & Usability Analysis
How do these features translate to the actual loading experience? Let’s talk feel and results.
Precision & Consistency
For tasks demanding ultimate consistency, like match-grade rifle ammunition, the Rebel’s O-frame and compound linkage offer a slight theoretical edge. The reduced flex and smoother operation can contribute to more uniform bullet seating and case sizing. This makes the RCBS Rebel vs Reloader Special 5 for precision reloading question lean toward the Rebel for pure benchrest pursuits.
That said, the Reloader Special 5 is incredibly capable. With good technique, you can produce highly accurate ammunition. The difference often comes down to the shooter, not the press. For a deeper dive on precision, our accuracy test comparison provides detailed data.
Durability & Long-Term Use
Both presses are built to last a lifetime. RCBS is famous for its iron-clad reloading press warrantya no-BS guarantee that stands behind their products. The durability comparison RCBS Rebel and Reloader Special 5 is essentially a tie. They’re both cast iron monsters.
The Rebel’s newer design incorporates some modern machining and finishes, but the Reloader Special 5’s simpler design has fewer parts that could theoretically wear. In practice, you’ll likely never wear out either. This is a core reason both are often cited in the best reloading press conversation.
Ease of Use for Beginners
Is one a better reloading press for beginners? The Reloader Special 5 wins on sheer simplicity. Its straightforward operation has a gentler learning curve. There’s less to figure out upfront.
The Rebel, with its primer management system, actually sets a better long-term habit for cleanliness from day one. However, its slightly more complex linkage might feel different to a first-timer. For a complete beginner’s overview, our full RCBS Rebel review covers all the basics.
Target User & Best Use Cases
So, who should buy which press? Let’s match the tool to the task.
The RCBS Reloader Special 5 User:
- The Traditionalist: You appreciate proven, simple mechanics. The C-frame design feels right.
- The Volume Pistol Reloader: You value fast case access and a reliable, rhythmic motion.
- The Budget-Conscious Buyer: You want maximum RCBS quality at a very competitive price point.
- The “Set It and Forget It” Reloader: You don’t mind adding a separate primer catch system.
The RCBS Rebel User:
- The Precision Hunter/Rifle Shooter: You prioritize press rigidity and smooth operation for rifle cartridges.
- The Neat Freak: The integrated spent primer system is a non-negotiable feature for you.
- The Modern Hobbyist: You appreciate thoughtful engineering updates that improve daily workflow.
- The Reloader Planning for Everything: The compound leverage gives you confidence for tough brass forming jobs.
Final Verdict & Buying Recommendation
This is the moment of truth. Which is better RCBS Rebel or Reloader Special 5? The answer, frustratingly, is “it depends.” But we can get specific.
Choose the RCBS Reloader Special 5 if:
- Your primary goal is the best value RCBS single stage press.
- You prefer the classic, open C-frame design for its accessibility.
- You load a high volume of straight-walled pistol cases.
- Simplicity and proven track record are your top priorities.
Choose the RCBS Rebel if:
- You demand maximum press rigidity for precision rifle loading.
- An integrated, clean spent primer system is a must-have.
- You frequently work with large or stubborn rifle brass and want the compound leverage advantage.
- You’re willing to invest a bit more for modernized features that enhance daily use.
Both are exceptional tools that will serve you flawlessly for decades. The Reloader Special 5 is the quintessential value-packed workhorse. The Rebel is the refined, feature-forward evolution. In the broader single stage press comparison landscape, including the ever-present RCBS vs Hornady press discussions, both of these RCBS models hold their own with sheer build quality.
Before you finalize your decision, always consult your reloading manual for specific data. The official source from bullet manufacturers like Nosler is an indispensable authority guide for safe practices. Your press is just one part of the equation. Good data, careful technique, and consistent components are what truly build great ammunition. Now, get to the bench.