Choosing your first single-stage reloading press is a big decision. It’s the cornerstone of your bench, a tool you’ll use for years. Two names dominate the conversation: the classic RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme and the newer RCBS Rebel Plus. Both promise precision and durability, but they approach the task differently.
You’re likely asking: which is better, the RCBS Rebel Plus or the Rock Chucker Supreme? The answer isn’t simple. It depends on your budget, your goals, and how you like to work. For many shooters building their first setup, the RCBS Rock Chucker kit remains a gold-standard recommendation due to its proven track record and comprehensive accessory package.
The Contenders in Single-Stage Reloading
RCBS has built its reputation on the Rock Chucker Supreme. It’s the press your grandfather might have used, a benchmark for reliability. The Rebel Plus entered the market as a modern contender, boasting design tweaks aimed at today’s reloader. Both are fantastic single stage reloading press options, but they cater to slightly different sensibilities.
This isn’t just about a press. It’s about the complete kitthe scales, the powder measure, the accessories. We’ll break down every component. Our goal is to help you decide the best reloading kit for a beginner on a budget or for the precision enthusiast seeking the ultimate tool.
Head-to-Head: Key Feature & Specification Comparison
Let’s get technical. A side-by-side look reveals where these presses diverge. The core difference lies in their mechanical design and user experience.
Frame & Construction
Both presses feature cast-iron construction. They’re heavy, rigid, and built to last a lifetime. The Rock Chucker uses a classic “O” frame design, while the Rebel Plus employs a “C” frame with an open front. This open design on the Rebel can make it easier to handle certain operations, like using a bullet puller.
Leverage & Mechanical Advantage
This is critical for sizing tough brass. The Rock Chucker Supreme utilizes a legendary compound linkage system. It provides immense mechanical advantage, making even the stiffest military brass feel smooth. The Rebel Plus uses a different linkage geometry. It’s still very strong, but some users report a slightly different feelstill excellent, just different. For a detailed look at how this translates to the bench, our rcbs accuracy test provides real-world data.
Primer Catcher System
A small thing that matters a lot. The Rock Chucker’s primer disposal is a known weak point; its system can be fiddly. The Rebel Plus addresses this with a vastly improved, positive-catching system that rarely spills spent primers. It’s a clear win for the Rebel in daily convenience.
Priming System
Both kits include an on-press priming arm. The Rock Chucker’s system is tried and true. The Rebel Plus system is also effective, but its design is integrated differently into the press frame. Many reloaders eventually opt for a handheld priming tool regardless, so this is often a secondary consideration.
| Feature | RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme | RCBS Rebel Plus |
|---|---|---|
| Frame Type | Traditional “O” Frame | Open Front “C” Frame |
| Linkage | Compound Linkage | Standard Linkage |
| Primer Catcher | Basic Tube | Enhanced Positive-Catch |
| Handle Angle | Fixed | Adjustable (Multiple Positions) |
| Ram Play | Extremely Minimal | Minimal |
Performance & Usability: Which Press Feels Better?
Specs on paper don’t tell the whole story. How do they actually feel during a long reloading session?
The Rock Chucker Supreme is famously smooth. Its compound linkage provides a buttery, powerful stroke that instills confidence. It’s a precision reloading press that feels like a precision instrument. The Rebel Plus is also smooth, but its stroke is more direct. Some prefer this more immediate feedback.
The Rebel’s adjustable handle is a genuine ergonomic benefit. You can find the perfect angle for your height and bench setup. The Rock Chucker’s fixed handle is fine, but it lacks this customization. For a deep dive into the Rock Chucker’s long-term performance, our rcbs in-depth review covers it all.
- Rock Chucker Feel: Powerful, leveraged, ultra-smooth. The classic choice.
- Rebel Plus Feel: Direct, solid, with modern ergonomics. The updated contender.
Which is better for precision? Both are capable of producing extremely accurate ammunition. The consistency of the press is more about its rigidity than its linkage type. Your technique and components will have a far greater impact. The Rock Chucker Supreme kit vs Rebel Plus kit for precision reloading debate often comes down to personal preference for the press’s “feel.”
Value Analysis: Breaking Down the Kits & Pricing
You’re rarely buying just the press. You’re investing in a starter kit. This is where the reloading kit comparison gets real. Both kits include the essentials, but the components differ.
The Rock Chucker Supreme Master Reloading Kit is the more established package. It typically includes:
- Rock Chucker Supreme Press
- Uniflow III Powder Measure
- M500 Mechanical Scale
- Hand Priming Tool
- Case Lube Kit, Tray, and Essential Accessories
The Rebel Plus Kit mirrors this but swaps in its namesake press. The accessory quality is identicalRCBS doesn’t cut corners here. The value proposition is tight. You must ask: does the Rebel Plus’s modern features (better primer catcher, adjustable handle) outweigh the Rock Chucker’s legendary status and proven linkage?
For a beginner, either kit provides a phenomenal foundation. The included scale (M500) is a beam scale, requiring patience to learn. Many shooters eventually upgrade to an electronic scale, but starting with a beam teaches fundamental consistency. It’s a great way to learn the craft, as outlined in this excellent authority guide to reloading basics.
What is the main difference between Rebel Plus and Rock Chucker?
If you need one sentence: The Rebel Plus offers modern ergonomic conveniences (handle, primer catcher) on a robust C-frame, while the Rock Chucker Supreme delivers unparalleled smoothness through its compound linkage on a classic O-frame. The choice is between refined tradition and thoughtful modernization.
Final Verdict: Who Should Buy Which Kit?
So, which kit deserves a spot on your bench? Let’s match them to the shooter.
Choose the RCBS Rock Chucker Supreme Kit If:
- You value proven, time-tested design above all.
- You want the maximum possible mechanical advantage for sizing brass.
- You appreciate the heritage and widespread community knowledge around this press.
- The classic feel of a best single stage press matters to you.
It remains the default for a reason. It’s the safe, excellent choice that will never let you down.
Choose the RCBS Rebel Plus Kit If:
- You prioritize daily ergonomics and convenience (that primer catcher!).
- You prefer an open-front C-frame for easier access.
- An adjustable handle is important for your comfort.
- You want a modern take on a classic tool without sacrificing RCBS quality.
It’s for the reloader who appreciates thoughtful updates to a classic formula.
For the beginner, there is no wrong answer. Both are outstanding reloading kits for beginners. Your decision might come down to which press you can find the best deal on, or which design aesthetically appeals to you more. The best value reloading kit is the one you’ll use consistently to produce safe, accurate ammunition.
The broader RCBS vs Hornady discussion is for another day. Within the RCBS family, you’re choosing between two champions. The Rock Chucker is the wise, experienced veteran. The Rebel Plus is the strong, agile newcomer. Both will help you build exceptional handloads for years to come. Trust your gut, then start loading.